Showing posts with label copyright infringement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label copyright infringement. Show all posts

Monday, 20 February 2017

Afro Leo

Putting a price on creativity- Nigerian musos insist on their rights

The African music scene is thriving and popular artists are set to share in a projected R309 million annual earning in 2019 on digital formats alone.

While artists on the continent compose lyrics to feed avid consumers, watchdogs are having to make a song and dance about telecoms companies using their tunes illegally.

This is very much the case in Nigeria where a lawsuit filed last year has been touted as the biggest copyright infringement in Africa.

In May 2016, the Copyright Society of Nigeria (COSON) took MTN to court over alleged infringements on musical copyrights, claiming 16 Billion Naira (around R700M) in damages.

According to COSON’s claim, MTN infringed copyrights in COSON’s musical and sound recordings in MTN Friendship, Connect and Walk In Centres across Nigeria.

The claims also extended to MTN road shows, various MTN Music Concerts, Festivals, and award Shows, as well as platforms such as mobile radio and product activations.

A recent study of the African entertainment sector by PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) accountants showed rapid earnings growth in many African countries, fuelled largely by live performances by local artists.

PwC’s Entertainment and Media outlook 2017 says that digital will account for the majority of spending on recorded music in Africa in 2019. According to the authors, the Nigerian music industry will grow at a projected 13% annually.

“Healthy growth in music revenues in Nigeria. Nigeria experienced a 3.8% rise in total music revenue in 2014 to US$51 million, up from US$50 million in 2013, as digital music began to make a larger impact. Annual revenue is forecast to grow by an estimated CAGR of 11.3% to reach US$88 million in 2019.”

Thirty-six year old D’Banj, also known as The Kokomaster, is believed to be the wealthiest musician in the country, followed by TuFace Idibia and Yemi Alade.

The PwC study states that download sales peaked in 2015 and revenue from consumer spending on physical formats would stand at R302 million in 2019, less than half the revenue figure in 2014. Lower ringback tone sales and a move to access over ownership is likely to reduce the share to just 14% in 2019.

Mondaq.com attribute the boost in intellectual rights in the entertainment sector to a rising unemployment.

“More Nigerian youths have discovered their creative talents and are now earning a living by creating intellectual and artistic works. International trade between Nigeria and other countries has contributed to the influx of international artistic works into the market. It is inevitable that owners of these works will only get their due return if they share in proceeds or obtain a fair compensation for their works,” says Emmanuel Ekpenyong writing on the site, adding that this can only be enforced if the work is actually registered with the copyright commission or COSON.

The Copyright society of Nigeria (COSON) is a collective management organization that registers artists and acts as the industry watchdog.

The Nigerian copyright  law, CAP C28 says that work eligible for copyright includes literary, musical and artistic works, cinematography films, sound recordings and broadcast material. The copyright can be conferred on the author who is domiciled in Nigeria or a citizen of the country.

COSON and MTN met out of court in December 2016, mediated by Prof Bankole Sodipo, in a bid to agree on a mediated settlement. Speaking after the meeting, COSON’s chair Tony Okoroji said a framework had been agreed upon in which to resolve the matter.

“The meeting also agreed that all parties and organisations associated with them should cease all adversarial actions henceforth to ensure that there is a conducive environment for the resolution. When we are done, every creative person and investor in the Nigerian music industry will benefit immensely from the engagement,” said Okoroji.

Funso Aina, spokesperson for MTN Nigeria, said the matter is still in court at its preliminary stage. 
"MTN has filed a defence against the action. On a related note, discussions are still ongoing between parties under the supervision of a mediator on a possible amicable resolution. The court adjourned the matter to April 4, in order for parties to report to the court on status of settlement discussions."

 
There is more on copyright enforcement in Nigeria from Afro-IP this week. Chijioke Ifeoma Okorie will be publishing a much awaited post on the judgment in Musical Copyright Society of Nigeria Ltd v Nigerian Copyright Commission. Stay tuned.



Read More

Friday, 2 September 2016

Afro Ng'ombe

IP and African Music Industries: An Interview with Phil Chard - part 4


Phil Chard
Part 4 of our interview* with Phil Chard brings us fascinating discussion on making a living as a musician on the continent and the thin line, the very grey areas, between infringement and licenses in Africa.  (Part 1; Part 2; Part 3)

Little Leo:  As you move through the industry and follow it and work with it in all your various capacities—you’ve been involved for quite a while, the African Hip Hop Blog is eight years old, 2 Broke Twimbos about two/two-and-a-half, what kind of longevity do you see in the music blogging industry?

Phil:  It all depends on what their long-term goals are, if they have long-term goals at all.  A lot of the stuff that I see now, I don’t see a lot of these guys surviving much longer because their business models are predicated on either content theft in some manner shape or form, or just empty content.  And eventually the consumer is going to wise up and be like these guys aren’t giving us reputable information.  And they’re going to stop going there.  But a lot of these companies they’re run by people who actually rely on that cycle.  So everything is on a two-year cycle.  They’ll start something; it’ll reach its peak, and as it starts to dip, they’ll move onto the next thing.  They’ll replicate the business model, but just under a new brand.

L:  Interesting.  And do you see artists, producers, songwriters—and maybe the answer’s different for each of these—and other people involved in the industry, do you see people who actually are able to make a living and make a career out of the content industry?

P:  Uh, yeah, it’s very country dependent.  So, if you’re looking at the three biggest markets in Africa in terms of entertainment: they are West Africa, which is essentially Nigeria and Ghana; Southern Africa, which is South Africa; and then East Africa, which is Malawi, Kenya, Tanzania.  Those are the biggest markets.  The most developed in terms of the music industry is South Africa.  Nigeria’s coming along now.  But I’m sure, as you know, artists still aren’t getting their needle time collections.  So, that’s limiting a great amount of revenue.  But, in terms of South Africa, guys can easily earn a very, very good living.  As long as they crack a certain threshold, they can survive on shows alone.  So you’ll see a lot of artists, they’ll actually predicate their whole careers on releasing free music and then their revenue stream is the shows and then endorsements here and there and that’s about it.

L:  And that’s mainly for South Africa?

P: Even in Nigeria.  In Nigeria, artists actually hire the pirates.  I don’t know if you know this.

L: Yeah, I actually have heard of that.

P:  So, when an artist releases an album, he’ll go and sell the master copy to a pirate.  And then that works on two levels: A) they’re getting paid for their work, because if they don’t give it to them, they’re not going to get paid anything.  And B) it helps spread their music.  The music spreading and then being played in taxis and in public allows them to gain popularity, which then translates into radio interviews and radio play, which then translates into performances.  And, performances in Nigeria are huge.  Guys get invited to private shows can get upwards of US$50,000 for a show.

L:  There are some big ogas in that country who will pay a lot for those.

P: So, it’s a very lucrative business for them over there.  But, they play all sides of the fence.  So, they’ll make sure it’s available for free and then you’ll also have sites like NotJustOk.  NotJustOk, for example, that’s a website predicated on dubious copyright practices.  But they’ve now become so big that artists need NotJustOk to plug them.

L:  So when artists do that, when they’re getting paid by the pirate, selling the initial copy to the pirate to then produce and give out, or they’re trying to solicit NotJustOk to play their music, when does it turn from being a pirate infringing thing into part of the industry and part of the business model?

P:  I think that’s what it’s become now.  Which is why I’ve said it’s a uniquely African situation.  Where in the beginning, you’d find like what NotJustOk would do is: They’d get the content. They’d then download it and they’d add their tags like “downloaded at NotJustOk.”  And they’d change all the id3 tags to make it all NotJustOk.  And that was how they’d promote themselves.

Before a certain time, artists didn’t realize that there were DMCA laws that were in their favor, that they could issue takedown notices to the websites, or that their content had been stolen.  They didn’t know how to go about retrieving stolen content.  And while they were figuring that out, NotJustOk was becoming this massive behemoth.  So now they realized, “If NotJustOk doesn’t plug my stuff and I don’t have access to their 2 million readers, I’m shooting myself in the foot.  So, I’d rather give them that song for free and then bank on getting money other places.”  And NotJustOk realizes that leverage.  In some instances, if an artist wants an album review, they’ll be like, “yeah, we’ll review your album, but we’re gonna pick 3 songs to give away for free.”

L: Sort of bargaining for the publicity?

P: Yeah.  And then there are other sites that are just operating off of straight payola.  So, they won’t review an album unless you pay them for the review.

L:  How do artists then handle infringement issues on the ground?  You’ve gotten into some of what the standard practices are, but in terms of artists protecting their work, what are the basic practices?  We don’t see a lot of lawsuits.  You’ve talked a bit about these kinds of agreements like with NotJustOk and things.  What other practices do they have if they know of another artist using their music or if they learn about some new way that it’s being distributed without their authorization?

P:  In most case, it’s hard to paint it with a very wide brush because it varies from case to case.  But with the incidents that I’ve seen across the board, it’s mainly the distributors and it’s mainly the labels themselves that understand these issues that enforce them.  So, for example we used to have a very active Soundcloud page.  We’ve scaled it down somewhat because of these issues. 

Artists would send us their music and be like “You guys really have a following on your SoundCloud page.  Please post my song on your SoundCloud page and then redirect them to my download page.” Or the iTunes page or whatever it may be.  What we then find is they would give us the song and they’d email us the written agreement, but they did not inform their distributor or their distributor did not have the mechanism in place to quote-unquote give us an exception.  So then we get takedown notices from SoundCloud that this song matches this song and has been removed from your account.

L:  Right.  We actually have issues with that here in some of our industries too, where different parts of a company don’t speak to each other and marketing sends something to be put up on YouTube and then legal sends something to have it taken down.

P:  Yeah, exactly.  And most of those issues, we’ll see that those takedown notices are being issued by the distributor or by the label, it’s rarely the artist.  Artists rarely—artists just want their music, especially in Africa right now, an artist just wants people to hear their music.  They’re thinking, and they see the quarterly statements from SAMRO and SAMPRO, whatever collecting agency they’re using, and they know that what they’re earning a quarter for a great selling cd does not compare to what they can earn in a weekend from shows.  So the whole revenue stream has now shifted from selling cds to getting bookings.

L:  And there are definitely artists who are out there petitioning their governments to crack down on piracy.  Nigeria, particularly, often makes a big show of going into Alaba market and other markets in the country and confiscating all the infringing cds and burning them and stuff.  {Example from a few years ago; example from this year.}  But at the same time, artists are making deals with otherwise-pirates.  They’re also kind of flaunting this lavish lifestyle, which you talked about in your rant, how especially when they get their first contract, they go out, they live like superstars but they can’t support it.  How much do you think that kind of thing, where they’re presenting to the government that they’re poor and they need help and they can’t survive without these extra laws or this extra enforcement, but then they’re turning around and showing the public that they’re extremely wealthy, how does the public perceive that?  How much does that hurt their brand or what they’re trying to accomplish?

P:  I think it’s pretty much the same as you guys.  So, in America with what happened between Metallica and Napster.  On the one hand, Metallica and Lars were pushing this whole thing like “these guys are taking money out of our pockets, blah blah blah,” and then you flip to MTV Cribs and there’s Lars with his twenty-room mansion and you’re like “but yeah, but I’m sure you’re doing ok.”  It’s the same thing here, but it’s also a double-edged sword in that artists have adopted the culture of materialism, the American culture of materialism.  So, you’ve got to sell the dream to get people to buy into you.  And you can only sell the dream in most cases by showing a lifestyle that you don’t live.  And then, by doing that, you’re now overdrawn, so you then need to go back to the government and be like “You might have seen the Lamborghini in my video, but that’s not my Lamborghini.  But you see, I really need to pay rent, so you guys need to help me get my money from these guys.”

But in most cases, I’ll give you an example:  Zimbabwe is almost as bad as Lagos in terms of this out-and-out piracy.  There’s an interview I did on 2BrokeTwimbos with someone called Sanii Mahkalima.  He used to run an independent label in the early 2000s.  And he was talking about how they used to, independently, they used to push 100,000 copies of a product.  And in Zimbabwe, that’s a very, very, big, big number.

What they used to do was, they used to go to the flea market.  So, they’d get their cds printed at Gramma Records, a legitimate place.  They’d pay them.  They’d then take these cds, because legitimate stores like Spin-a-Long which is like your Tower Records, they weren’t accepting these cds.  They were like “No, we don’t know these names; we don’t know you guys.  We’re not taking the risk. No.”  So they’re like “Ok, fine; we’re going to the flea markets.”  So the guys at the flea markets, they’d start by leaving their cds and then collecting money at the end of the week.  But then demand got so high that guys at the flea market were like, “No, we’ll pay up front.”  And then demand got so supremely high that guys were now bartering for exclusive deals like, “I’ll take all your cds.  But you gotta promise you not going to see to anyone else at this flea market, so I’m the only person at this flea market with the cd.”  And then they’d use that, you know, to control the price or try to upsell and sell other stuff.

The government then instituted a program called Murambatsvina, but what they did is they banned flea markets and they demolished a lot of the shacks and shanty towns that were developing in the high density suburbs, which was to disperse the political opposition.  But what that also created is that now, you’ve destroyed the distribution model for all these independent artists.  All these kids that were my generation, we’d stopped buying stuff from Spin-A-Long, which was the main distributor, because they weren’t stocking the music that we liked.  We would go to the flea market, because the flea market had all the hip hop and all the urban music from America and the local stuff.  But now, because flea markets have now become illegal, we do not know where to get the stuff. 

And around that very time, which is around 2005/2006, there are guys like Dash, who would download all this music and then plaster their name all over the stuff and then distribute these cds.  So they’d start burning mp3s and on that mp3 would be like 20 albums.  You’d go to school and people were just passing around everyone’s cd, and you copied it to your harddrive.  Now you’ve got all the latest music, which you’ve got for free.  And you now know where to get it, because they put their cell number like on the artist’s tags and everything so next...

L:  Like Mike Jones.

P:  No, Mike Jones [laughs].  You know what id3 tags are right?  So literally, artists’ tags would say “Dash Mike Jones” then his cell phone number.  Album, “Dash Mike Jones” then his cell phone number.  Lyrics, just a long repetitive list of his cell phone number.  So now you know, whenever you want to get new music, you call this guy.  And then there were guys that would burn cds.  So there were guys like Dash where you would go into town and these guys would—I can’t remember the figures but it was somewhere above a dollar figure—you could get cds burned by these guys and then they’d burn you mix cds and they would charge you a nominal fee.  And then they’d download this music from the internet overnight or they’d get it from friends overseas and that type of stuff.

I actually used to do that when I was in high school.  That’s how I’d pay for sneakers when I was in school.  Like I’d buy a cd and burn it and stuff like that, before I understood it was illegal.  But now, you’ve got a whole generation of kids that were used to getting music from these sources.  So instead of paying USD$10 for a cd or whatever it may be, they’re now playing 15₵ for a burned cd, and the burned cd is an mp3, so instead of 20 songs, they’ve got 200 songs.  And that then evolved into the flashstick generation.  And that now has evolved into the internet, where there’s a whole generation of kids my age and going down, that the concept of walking into a store, especially in a country like Zimbabwe, even in like Zambia and Kenya, even in Nigeria, the concept of walking into a store and giving someone money and getting a cd that’s sealed, that’s completely foreign to them.

L: Right.  Zambia used to have Mondo Music, but it closed, gosh when did I hear about it closing?  Maybe 2008, 2010, sometime around there.  But that used to be the place to get the Zambian music, or to get any cds before Game really had come in.

P:  Yeah, so now like, even in Zambia now, you’ve got Musica, But that is predicated on South African distribution models, so local acts aren’t getting in.  The same guy that told me about this issue with the Zambian music rights {see end of part 3] told me the same thing, in Zambia, artists don’t even consider record sales.  They’re just trying to get a next big hit so they can start getting bookings because that’s how they make their money, on bookings.

L: How much are artists looking for—when you talk about performances and stuff and that being the way to make money—how much are they looking beyond their own borders, looking to the rest of the continent or looking to the rest of the world?

P:  Once again, it’s very country-by-country.  South Africa was an island upon itself up until probably about 2 years ago to be honest.  I think the only artist that actually saw a continental reach were house acts.  And South Africa’s in a very unique position because South Africa controls African media reach.  All the satellite stations are headquartered in South Africa, so they have easy access and direct access to these stations, which are then distributed to the rest of the continent.  Bongo Maffin and Oskido, saw it early.  I think Oskido was one of the first, first artists to realize the global appeal.  And he’s been doing his show in Miami for the past decade, every winter.  But in terms of hip hop acts, they had no idea that other countries existed up until last year.

L:  I’d say that matches with my somewhat boxed-in perspectives.  I live in a bubble; I’m aware of that.  But I’d say in terms of what I’ve seen filtering through and getting to me here in America, even being somebody who looks for it, I think that matches.

We’ll stop there for today.  Join us for the last installment of this interview where we’ll talk about what, if anything, the legal system can do to improve the music industry in Africa.
*The conversation has been edited for clarity and reading ease; it is not an exact transcript.
Read More

Thursday, 1 September 2016

Afro Ng'ombe

IP and African Music Industries: An Interview with Phil Chard - part 3


Zambian Music Copyright Protection Society,
interesting agreements?
Welcome back for part 3 of our interview* with Phil Chard.  We left off discussing artists’ respect for their craft.  Today, we’re going to get into how artists interact with copyright law.  A brief recap of where we were last time is at the top in grey. (Part 1; Part 2)

Little Leo:  It sounds like you’re also saying in some ways the artists don’t respect their craft, that they’re not taking it seriously.

Phil:  To a certain extent, it’s true.  There’s a culture here, a microwavable culture.  Everyone is trying to get the next big hit, the next big headline, the next trending topic, with no real consideration to the long-term ramifications of what they’re doing.  And it gets frustrating.  Even large organizations, they’ll rather have a quote-unquote Twitter celebrity do an absolutely pointless interview than have people that actually produce quality editorial content do that stuff.  And it seeps down to the consumer because now the consumer is like “why should I spend 30 minutes of my time watching this good interview, when I can watch a listicle that’s 3 minutes, that tells me nothing but is entertaining.”  So, it now devalues the content across the board.

Phil (cont.): There’s so many other things, like artists will complain about piracy, and people not paying for their music, but they’ll go and download or illegally steal someone’s content.  Just last week, we had an interview we did with an artist called HHP.  I’ve known HHP for quite some time.  He respected the fact that whenever he’d do major events he’d always see me there.  And I’d always be flying in to cover these events.  He was impressed by the fact that I was always there.  He was asking me, “Dude, are you based here?”  I’m like, “No, I’m flying in and out; I’ve got a day job.  This is what I do on the weekends because I care for the culture.”  He had just got out of rehab.  He had suffered a bout of depression; he had attempted suicide.  He went on the radio and spoke about it.  And then they put him on meds and he wasn’t happy with the side-effects of the meds, so he went to rehab to wean himself off the medication.  And he was going to deal with the depression naturally.  So he met me after he just got out of rehab, and he was like, “come to my house tomorrow; I’m going to give you the best interview you’ve ever had.”

So we go to his house.  We spent like the whole day with him.  It was actually a great experience.  Then during the interview, he goes on a rant about disrespectful young artists that are talking out of turn, that basically feel the need to mention older artists’ names and saying “I’m now better than this artist.”  That, “now I make more money than this artist.”  And he was like, “That’s extremely disrespectful and in my culture we don’t do that.”  And he had some very choice words, some very apt words, and that section of the interview went viral.

People started taking it out of context, which kind of annoyed me because that’s the last thing I wanted to do.  I’d actually held onto that interview for a couple of weeks because I was weighing it, “if I release this, there’s a good and there’s a bad.”  And I didn’t want any negative energy to come over him because I respect this man as an artist.  But, all that being said, this interview goes extremely viral.  I keep getting these pings off other websites and other blogs, downloading the video and re-uploading it as their own.  Now I’m playing whack-a-mole on Facebook, reporting all these cases, and on YouTube.

And then last week, an artist who had actually complained about people illegally downloading his music, takes this interview, samples it in a song, and then he hosts it on another blog.  And this artist, I’ve interviewed him several times.  He knows me and he knows my number.  His producers know me.  Not one of them thought to contact me and at least just get permission and ask, “Hey, Phil, we’ve got your content; we want to use it in a song.  Would you mind if we use it?”  And it’s a free song; I’m not going to charge them for it.  The least I would do is say, “Ok, that’s great guys, use the sample, but at least give me the exclusive so I can host it on my site so it’s mutually beneficial to both of us.”  But now another website is benefiting from my content and I am just stuck holding my hands doing nothing.

That’s a common thing that they do.  They’ll complain about downloads but they’ll blatantly sample an American song.  You find, Cassper Nyovest was also  ranting about people not respecting his music.  But there’s a Childish Gambino song called “Heartbeat”; there’s a melody bar-for-bar, they stole that whole melody and he used it in one of his songs ("Style Se Legit").  He’s got another song called “Mama I Made It,” that’s a carbon copy of a Drake song, beats, melody, rhyme pattern, everything.  His breakout hit, “Doc Shebeleza”, the chord progression was a direct carbon copy of a Lex Luger beat.  Lex Luger’s a producer for Rick Ross.  So, there’s just a culture of mediocrity, that’s what we call it here.

Everyone is very happy with the status quo.  They’re very happy middle of the road.  No one is trying to be exceptional.  And if they do try to be exceptional, they pull you back into the pack very quickly.  You don’t want to be the odd one out.  That’s when they start casting you out.  “Oh, you said this, ok, you’re not getting invited to this event anymore.  Oh, you bothered to talk about this, ok, you’re not getting this exclusive anymore.”

L:  Bringing it back to the copyright issues a bit, I definitely hear it, it’s clear you do, too: the artists complaining about infringement with downloads, but then turning around and doing it themselves.  How much do you get the impression that artists actually understand copyright or are familiar with it?

P:  They understand it when it directly affects them.  I don’t know if you caught the #CreditTheCreator hashtag that went viral about three weeks ago.  {See also #CreditThePhotographer.} 

L:  I think I missed that one.

P:  Basically what had happened, there’s a photographer called Austin Malema.  Austin Malema was invited to the SAMAs, the South African Music Awards, to take photos backstage.  He was doing it on his own capacity, he wasn’t hired by the SAMAs.  He just got a pass and was taking them for himself.  One of the photos he took, he took a photo of a celebrity called Pearl Thusi , and he posted it on his Instagram page and he tagged her.  She then liked the photo and reposted it.  When she reposted it, she didn’t give him credit, and she says, ‘I don’t know who took this photo, but I love it.”  He got irate, “but you know who took it because you liked it and you saw it on my page.”  Her argument was that “you could have just have easily taken that photo from someone else so I can’t really verify that you took it.” 
There were obviously some conversations behind the scenes that led to this.  After he explained that it was his photo, she still refused to credit him.  He got very irate and sent a takedown notice to Instagram.  Instagram took down the photo.  She then retaliated and said, “since you asked Instagram to take down the photo from my page, I will ask you to take your photo of me from your page.” 
And then people who are familiar with how intellectual property works were like, “That’s not how it works because you were in a public venue and he’s not using this photo for commercial gain.  It’s just for his page.  If you don’t credit him, that’s a loss of revenue because there’s an investment he’s made in getting to the venue, paying for the equipment, etc.”  And then the argument raged on where artists were on the side of “Why are you taking photos of me?  If you don’t want me to repost your photos, don’t take photos of me.”  And we were like “That’s not how it works because you were in a public space.  If you’re in a public space, we have the right to take photos of you as long as it’s not incriminating.  And if we’re not selling the photos, then it’s fair use.”  Artists clearly didn’t understand that concept and they’re like. “Well we’re the celebrities; we have rights to those photos.” 
There’s also a photographer called Michelle Hunder.  She’s from Australia.  She caught wind of this and she sent me an article.  She had the same issue with a rapper from America called Danny Brown.  He did the same thing.  He put a photo up of hers.  Her editor then got hold of him and said, “Thanks for posting the photo but do you mind just crediting the photographer because that’s the only way she’s going to get credit.”  And then he threw a rant and said, “No, I’m just going to take the photo down.”  And then that was that.

L:  So much fighting just over credit, not even remuneration or anything like that.

P:  That’s it.  Even me, I’m a photographer.  I’ll see it so many times.  I’ll take a photo of an artist.  I’ll tag them.  They’ll repost it.  They won’t credit me.  And they’ll ruin the photo with filters.

L:  I wanted to switch to some other areas of IP.  We started getting a little into rights of publicity with the artists saying “well that’s of me, so take it down.”  And you’ve already touched on the public place sort of aspect.  You also talked a bit about brands and artists knowing their brands and taking brand ownership.  How often do you see artists and people in the industry using the legal tools that are available to them for brand ownership, things like trademark registrations and that?

P:  It’s hard to determine because a lot of that stuff is behind the scenes.  I’m trying to think of a copyright infringement case that actually went through.  Off-hand, I really can’t think of any copyright infringement cases that have been filed.

L:  Well we had the recent one with TIGO that you guys talked about on the African Hip Hop Blog [at 5:30 mark].

P:  Yes.

L:  MTN’s had a couple issues.

P:  If I’m not mistaken both MTN in South Africa and Nigeria, there’s some pending aspects on payments.  Those are definitely the big ones.  There’s another network provider that also has an issue with callback tones.  In most instances, that’s when artists recognize that their copyrights are being infringed upon.  When their music is being distributed and they aren’t seeing any remuneration for it. 
There’s something going on in Zambia.  The Zambian music rights association [ZAMCOPS]is basically shifting all its artists.  There’s a guy from Zambia who came down and we were discussing the scene.  He showed me a deed of assignment that’s been issued by ZAMCOPS, which already struck me as odd because I’m like, “why would they be issuing deeds of assignment for works?”  One of the clauses basically states that upon signing this contract all artists are surrendering all mechanical and performing rights to their works to the bearer, the bearer being ZAMCOPS.  Thereafter, I already knew exactly what they were doing.  Then I asked him, have there been any artists who have seen their music being distributed without their knowledge?  And he said, “Yes, there’s actually a couple of artists who have their music on iTunes, which they never put on iTunes. " And when they checked, it says under copyright from the Zambian Music Copyright Protection Society.  And they’ve never received payment for this.  Basically, an organization purporting to be for the rights of the artists is stealing their content, stealing their rights, distributing their content, and not remunerating them for it.

We’ll break here for today.  Join us next time, when we delve further into contractual agreements and get into trade secrets a bit.
 
*The conversation has been edited for clarity and reading ease; it is not an exact transcript.

Read More

Saturday, 2 July 2016

Afro Ng'ombe

Big Win for Copyright and Artists in Tanzania

Back in May, a large variety of news outlets announced a major copyright victory for two Tanzanian musicians, rappers AY (Ambwene Yessaya) and MwanaFA (Hamisi Mwinjuma), against telecom operator Tigo (MIC Tanzania Limited).  According to its Wikipedia page [which reads like it was written by Tigo’s PR department], the company is owned by European-based Millicom International Cellular.  The High Court’s decision in an appeal was supposed to be released on June 27, but Little Leo wasn’t able to find much on the High Court of Tanzania website, or elsewhere, in terms of a written decision from either the High Court or District Court.  As also, Afro Leo would love if someone has either decision to share.

Here’s what we know based on what’s been circulating in the news.  Tigo was selling AY and MwanaFA’s music to Tigo customers to use as caller tunes (called ringback tunes in America), the music that can replace the standard telephone ring a caller hears while waiting for the line to be answered.  At least two songs released on the Bongo label were at issue in the case, “Dakika Moja” (“One Minute”) and “Usije Mjini,” which were both written and performed by the duo.  The case was brought before Magistrate Juma Hassan in Ilala District Court (a district in Dar es Salaam) in 2012 and was decided on April 11, 2016.  The court held that Tigo infringed the rights of AY and MwanaFA’s musical works.  Tigo was ordered to pay Tsh 2.16 billion (about 2 to 3 million bottles of Coca Cola) in special damages and costs and another Tsh 5 billion or 25 million, depending on your source, in general damages. 

Tigo’s appeal brought the story back into the news again in May.  Tigo filed for a stay of execution with the High Court, arguing that the actual damage suffered by the artists was not proven and that the court should consider the benefits the artists received because of Tigo’s work to create and offer the caller tones with their songs.  [Presumably that magical “promotional” benefit for which all artists should be happy to work.]  Tigo also is arguing that the artists cannot prove rights to the songs because they do not have registrations from the Copyright Society of Tanzania (Cosota, which is the collecting society authorized by the Copyright Act, Art. 46 and the entity listed with WIPO as being the national copyright office).

What is unknown is which rights the court held were infringed.  Ringback tunes present interesting issues here that often turn into interesting arguments.  (Citations to articles in The Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act 1999)  Are the ringback tunes adaptations because they are only a part of the song? (4(1)(f).)  Did (or does when the tune plays) the telecom company reproduce the work? (4(1)(a).)  Is the ringback tune a public performance even though it only plays to one person at a time because it could play to anybody and does play to multiple people over the time it’s in use? (4(1)(g).)  Is the telecom distributing the work by sending the ringback tone to its customer’s phones? (4(1)(b).)  It would be interesting to see how the court sorted these answers under Tanzanian law.  Also, was it only the musical works that were held to be infringed?  What about the phonogram/sound recording rights (32(1).) or performance rights (31(c) and (f).)?  We know that AY and MwanaMF wrote the songs and performed them.  Did they also produce them?  Are producer’s rights held by their label, Bongo Flava [likely], and was the label a plaintiff in the case?

Tigo’s registration issue is also unclear.  There’s no registration requirement in the Tanzanian Copyright Act.  It sounds like (see Mwananchi below) they are arguing that the artists must prove their collecting society membership in order to sue, but it is unclear from the information available whether Cosota was the (or a) plaintiff.  Most of the reports make it sound like the artists themselves won the damages, but one can easily see how the press might confuse a collecting society or label winning on behalf of an artist who was infringed with the artist winning.  [Of course, if it was Cosota or Bongo Flava, one would wonder why only sue for these two songs.  According to The Citizen (see below), most of the caller tones in use in Tanzania belong to Bongo Flava.] 

Lastly, what are those “general damages”?  The reports seem pretty clear that the Tsh 2.6 billion are actual damages for the plaintiffs.  But the reports interchangeably refer to the other amount (the 5 billion or 25 million) as “damages” and “fines.”  Article 36(1)(b) allows the court to award exemplary damages “if the infringement is found to have been prejudicious to the reputation of the person whose rights were infringed.”  Is that what happened here?  The Copyright Act also has a “sanctions” provision for knowingly infringing on a commercial basis, which allows the court to impose a fine up to Tsh 5 million or 3 years imprisonment (42(1)(a).)  This seems like an odd criminal remedy in a civil suit, but perhaps that is what is going on here, though neither proffered amount matches the limit. In any case, is this extra amount a fine that goes to the government or additional damages that go to the plaintiffs?

There’s a lot left to find out, but one thing is very clear—and it’s been said by the plaintiffs—having copyright upheld in court is a big win for young artists in East Africa.

Similar cases have been brought in Kenya--where Safaricom settled with JB Maina for using his works in ringtones without his approval—,and in Nigeria, where MTN is in trouble again.

News sources for the case:
Mwananchi
The Citizen
Daily Nation
Hat tip to African Hip Hop Blog and their Podcast for discussing the story

Read More

Monday, 28 September 2015

Afro Leo

Significant damages awarded in software infringement case in RSA

It's not often that we get a case involving copyright enforcement in the software space especially against a government department, by a local software developer and where significant damages are awarded. In the recent case of Quill v Randfontein Local Municipality (RLM), local software developer (Quill) sued RLM for copyright infringement in respect of their BIQ software product and in the process obtained over R10million (-+$1million) in damages (a large amount by RSA standards).

Five key points to be canvassed shortly by Nic Rosslee in this week's #SandtonDiscussion at 9am CAT are:

  • the nature of copyright in software in South Africa as a separate category of work
  • the inadequacy of RLM's defenses
  • benefits of using trial proceedings under these circumstances
  • the court's interpretation of a reasonable royalty
  • the refusal to grant leave to appeal 
The timing of this case is apt in that it endorses the need for education (even within government departments) about the need to pay attention to software licenses. A recent post on the work of Amanda Lotheringen (DTI) and the Billa Coetsee (BSA) whose teams have launched a world first compliance campaign explains more about that here.

Hosted by Adams & Adams.
Tune in at 9am for more. 
Read More

Tuesday, 14 February 2012

Darren Olivier

Nigeria: Production Company Sues Virgin Atlantic Airlines for Copyright Infringement

Courtesy of Chukwuyere Izuogu (Streamsowers & Köhn):

Yo Virgin...

"The producer of Nollywood movie “Ghetto Dreamz” has instituted a N1 Billion (approximately USD 6,221,340) lawsuit against Virgin Atlantic Airlines Nigeria for copyright infringement. Ope Banwo the CEO of the production company alleges that the full length of the movie was played on over 71 international routes by the defendant company.


Justice Adah of the Federal High Court sitting at the Ikeja Judicial Division, Lagos on the 2nd February 2012 granted an injunctive relief restraining the defendant Virgin Atlantic Airlines Nigeria Ltd whether by themselves, agents, privies, management, directors, pilots, flight crew, etc from infringing or continuing to infringe the copyrights in Ghetto Dreams.


Ghetto Dreams which premiered in April 2011 is a biopic of Dagrin (Oladapo Olaitan Olaonipekun), A Nigerian Hip-Hop Artiste who died on 22nd April 2010 at the tender age of 22 from fatal injuries sustained in car crash.


The case has been adjourned to 12 March 2012."

Chukwuyere, we look forward to further updates - thank you.

Afro Leo says this is not the first time Virgin Nigeria has been accused of copyright infringement. Click here for more
Read More